The risks of late estate planning
December 2018

Imagine you are named as the executor and a beneficiary of your wife’s wealthy aunt.  You learn that she is suffering from terminal cancer and has ‘a very impaired lifespan’.  What do you do?

This is what happened in the case of Nader and others v Revenue & Customs.  The executor/beneficiary, a Dr Nader, decided to consult a leading firm of accountants about inheritance tax (IHT) mitigation options for Miss Dickins (the aunt).

The accountants put forward an offshore trust-based scheme, provided by a third party, which would remove the IHT liability on £1,000,000 of Miss Dickins’ estate.  The scheme was highly complex, involving multiple trusts and short-term loans.  It cost a total of £100,000 in fees and its first stage was triggered on 6 December 2010, three weeks before Miss Dickins’ death.

Dr Nader received grant of probate on 4 July 2011 and a little over a month later the scheme was wound up, with IHT-free payments being made to Miss Dickins’ beneficiaries.  However, subsequently HMRC opened an enquiry into the IHT return and by February 2015 – a little over four years after Miss Dickins’ demise – tax demands were issued to the beneficiaries.

Wind forward another three years and at a First Tier Tribunal (Tax), Dr Nader, together with his fellow beneficiaries, made an appeal against the tax bills they were facing.  In a 51-page judgement, the Tribunal dismissed the scheme as ineffective, and the beneficiaries were also left with the appeal legal costs on top of the bill for IHT plus outstanding interest.

The case is a reminder of the risks, costs and protracted timescales that can be involved in deathbed estate planning.

There are many ways to mitigate the impact of IHT, but the sooner planning starts, the better.  It is all too easy to defer such planning – as with writing a will – but delays can carry a high price.  If you need an advice on IHT planning, please get in touch with us.


The content of this publication is for information purposes and should not be treated as a forecast, research or advice to buy or sell any particular investment or to adopt any investment strategy.  It does not provide personal advice based on an assessment of your own circumstances.  Any views expressed are based on information received from a variety of sources which we believe to be reliable, but are not guaranteed as to accuracy or completeness. Any expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice.

The value of tax reliefs depends on your individual circumstances.

Tax laws can change.

The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate tax or trust advice, will writing and some forms of estate planning.

This entry was posted in Topical Updates.

Comments are closed.